Against Empire (1995) by Michael Parenti argues that U.S. foreign policy is driven mainly by the interests of corporations and investors, not by a mission to defend democracy. It is a short, forceful book in the tradition of anti-imperialist writing.
What Is Against Empire About?
Parenti reviews examples of U.S. military and political intervention abroad and argues that they follow a pattern: protecting access to resources, markets, and investment opportunities and opposing governments that try to control them. He also discusses how the media and public debate frame these interventions.
Key Ideas
- Empire as an economic system. He argues that global power is tied to capital and its need to expand.
- The stated reasons vs. the real ones. He suggests that humanitarian or security goals often hide economic motives.
- Impact on poorer countries. He claims that intervention and economic pressure hold back development and democracy elsewhere.
- The role of public opinion. He argues that media and political language make these policies look more benevolent than critics say they are.
Criticisms and Limits
Critics say Parenti presents a one-sided case that treats economic interest as the single driver of foreign policy, while historians point to other factors such as security concerns, ideology, domestic politics, and mistakes. The book also dates from the 1990s, so it does not cover more recent events. Reading it together with mainstream diplomatic histories gives a fuller picture.
My Perspective
As a Marxist and a humanist, I’m interested in the connection between economic power and political power, and in how the people affected by foreign policy are often left out of the story. I believe knowledge should be accessible to everyone, including histories that governments would rather not emphasize. At the same time, I try to read with a skeptical eye, and I think a single explanation rarely covers a complex history. I find that applying critical thinking to every account, including the ones I am more inclined to agree with, gives a better understanding.
Questions Worth Discussing
- Are economic interests the main driver of foreign policy?
- How do media shape how we see foreign interventions?
- What would a more democratic foreign policy look like?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Against Empire about?
It is a book by Michael Parenti arguing that U.S. foreign policy mainly serves corporate and investor interests.
When was Against Empire published?
In 1995.
Is it a balanced account?
No, it is an openly critical argument. Reading it with other historians gives a better overall view.
Conclusion
Against Empire is a sharp critique that raises uncomfortable questions about power and motives. Read it as one voice in a larger debate.
What do you think? Is foreign policy mostly about interests, or about values and security? I’d like to hear your thoughts, so feel free to get in touch.
Related Reading
Want to keep reading? These related posts pair well with this one:
